
From the “Staff and Hammer” Blog
By Dan Hult
In those days there was no king in Israel. Everyone did what was right in his own eyes.
-Judges 21:25
These words conclude the tumultuous book of Judges, following one of the most disturbing stories in the entire Bible. While the story of Deborah highlights the absence of good men, the Gibeah incident of Judges 19 shows how that absence spawned Sodom-like depravity, sparking the civil war and mass kidnapping that precede this verse. Our society similarly throws off the restraints of God’s created order in the name of liberty. God’s design is biblical patriarchy, which we recently explored in marriage, the home, the local church, and society. God appoints certain men to lead our institutions, gives them responsibilities to fulfill, and gives them the authority required to fulfill those responsibilities.
As we saw last time, abusive patriarchs forget their responsibility, seeking their own interests rather than caring for those God has entrusted to them. The antidote to these abusive patriarchs is godly patriarchs holding them accountable. However, our society has attempted the opposite solution: abandoning patriarchy entirely. Feminism has essentially driven the good men out of every sphere, and abusers—male and female—have filled the void. Two stories highlight this problem.
Lindsay Clancy and Destructive Feminism
The first is the trial of Lindsay Clancy, who claimed that postpartum psychosis led her to strangle her three children.[1] A mistrial was declared after a lone male juror refused call Clancy innocent.[2] Clancy’s case is not isolated.[3] In 1954, Constance Fisher was ruled insane after murdering her three children. She later had three more children and murdered them as well. Andrea Yates claimed that postpartum depression led her to drown her five children in 2001. What is unique about Clancy is how many women flocked to her defense, claiming that she should not be held responsible because the mental health system failed her. Some have even followed in her footsteps. Since the trial began in July, at least eight mothers have murdered or attempted to murder their children.[4] How is this possible? The short answer: feminism.
Decades of feminism have infected society with three tumors: unquestioned female virtue, downplayed gender differences, and hatred of children. First, most people simply accept that women are inherently virtuous, noble, and wise, while men are inherently evil, lustful, and toxic. Under this view, everything women do must be accepted or excused. If a woman abandons her family, it must be her husband’s fault. If she cannot find a husband, all men must be toxic and undeserving of her. If she accuses a man of anything, she must be believed without question and he must be condemned without trial or evidence. If she murders her children, “mental health”—or her husband—must be to blame. Mental health has long been society’s scapegoat to avoid accountability. In 1960, the president of the American Psychological Association observed:
For several decades, we psychologists looked upon the whole matter of sin and moral accountability as a great incubus and acclaimed our liberation from it as epoch-making. But at length we have discovered that to be “Free” in this sense, i.e., to have the excuse of being “sick” rather than sinful, is to court the danger of also becoming lost …. In becoming amoral, ethically neutral, and “free,” we have cut the very root of our being; lost our deepest sense of self-hood and identity; and, with neurotics themselves, find ourselves asking: Who am I? What is my destiny? What does living (existence) mean?
-O. Hobart Mowrer, ““Sin”: The Lesser of Two Evils”, American Psychologist 15:5, 1960.
The answers to questions of identity, destiny, and meaning are found in Scripture, which describes our condition as depravity (Jeremiah 17:9), not mental illness. Mental illnesses like postpartum depression exist and can contribute to sin, but they do not excuse sin. Regardless of her mental state, Lindsay Clancy is responsible for the sin of murdering her children.
The second tumor is an education system and society overall that downplays the differences between men and women. That leaves women ill-equipped to understand themselves and regulate their emotions. They see their emotions and hormones as mental illnesses to be medicated or soothed with affirming therapy rather than a uniquely-feminine struggle to be endured and overcome. When that meets women’s God-given ability to sympathize with others, they excuse murderous mothers like Lindsay Clancy.
To these women, affirmation of women is far more important than justice for three children who died at their mother’s hand because of the third tumor of feminism: hatred of children. Scripture views children as a blessing from God deserving of life because they are people made in the image of God from the point of conception. In contrast, feminists see children as a burden that prevents women from living fulfilled lives, so they vehemently defend a mother’s “right” to murder them. In Massachusetts, where the trial took place, the lesbian governor recently signed a law allowing abortion up to birth. If a woman gets to decide if her children are people deserving of life and dignity, there is nothing wrong with Lindsay Clancy deciding hers weren’t and performing a “post-birth abortion”. It is unsurprising then that many women are defending her and some are copying her—they are acting on what feminism has taught them.
Women Need Biblical Patriarchs
As with everything else wrong in the world, the solution is to fulfill the Cultural Mandate by restoring what has been damaged by the Fall. God created men and women to be interdependent (1 Corinthians 11:11-12), so a wife needs her husband just as much as a husband needs his wife. She needs her husband to lead her, to relieve stress from her by applying his rationality to big decisions, and to help regulate her emotions. She needs the security he provides. She needs him to exercise his authority in teaching and disciplining their children. She needs her husband to reject passivity and bear the responsibility that God designed him—not her—to bear. A big part of that responsibility is providing for the family adequately enough that his wife is able to focus on the home and family. In essence, she needs her husband to be a biblical patriarch.
A wife also needs women who can help her—not peers with whom to share gossip and gripes, but mature women to provide her with wisdom and instruction. God commands older women to train younger women in loving their husbands and children, self-control, purity, managing their homes, kindness, and submitting to their husbands (Titus 2:3-6). Feminism has permeated the American church, so older women that have the wisdom and skill to teach these things are scarce. Along with feminism, individualism has infected the church so thoroughly that many Christians do not believe they have a duty to hold each other accountable and help each other grow. Older, godly women should seek out younger women, build intentional relationships with them, and provide them with help and practical knowledge. Younger women should seek out and build purposeful relationships with older, godly women, inviting them into their homes and asking them to teach practical homemaking skills. A major purpose for any women’s ministry within the church should be to facilitate these relationships and help women learn practical skills. The more we do this, the easier it will be for a struggling wife to find women who can help her.
When the help of a husband and older women is not enough, God gives pastors who will comfort, guide, rebuke, and train wives and husbands in righteousness—not therapists who will affirm their emotions while overlooking their sin. Finally—and most importantly—God gives us Himself, the ultimate Patriarch. A wife who is struggling must run to Christ and cast her burdens upon Him (1 Peter 5:7).
Mica Miller and Abusive Pastors
The Lindsay Clancy story demonstrates the need for biblical patriarchy to counteract feminism, but the story of Mica Miller shows its importance on the opposite end of the spectrum. The Netflix docuseries Death of the Pastor’s Wife chronicles Mica’s tumultuous marriage to JP Miller and the events leading to her suicide. Their relationship began as an adulterous affair while JP was her pastor and they were both married to other people.[5] The pastor must be a one-woman man (1 Timothy 3:2, Titus 1:6), so JP Miller biblically disqualified himself by committing adultery with Mica. He should have been removed as soon as that relationship came to light. Instead, he remained a pastor while they divorced their spouses and married each other. They appeared to be the “perfect couple”, but behind closed doors, JP exerted “coercive control” over every aspect of Mica’s life.[6] In her divorce note, she described him as physically, emotionally, sexually, spiritually, and financially abusive.[7]
Feminists use this story as proof of rampant misogyny in the church, alleging that churches teaching on the authority of pastors and husbands perpetuate the type of abuse Mica Miller endured. In truth, this situation reveals deep, systemic problems in the American church that can be resolved—at least in part—by embracing biblical patriarchy. Mica Miller is dead in part because good patriarchs didn’t hold JP Miller accountable. Mica often tried to reach out to friends in the church for help. That should have spurred righteous men to intervene following the church discipline process in Matthew 18. If they found reason to believe Mica’s story, they would become the witnesses required to bring charges against an elder (1 Timothy 5:20). They never did, ultimately leading the church to shut down after Mica’s death.[8] JP Miller continues to preach in smaller gatherings even as he faces various legal charges.[9]
Any of JP’s abuse could have triggered such concern, but his sexual abuse definitely warranted intervention.[10] He demanded sex multiple times daily, even depriving Mica of sleep until she complied.[11] At this point, it is important to differentiate a biblical view of sex from both JP’s behavior and the predominant view in most churches. The docuseries showed JP preaching that sex is a wife’s obligation as her husband’s helpmate and that if a wife doesn’t satisfy her husband sexually, he will face a myriad of temptations.[12] As much as the effeminate American church resists it, his statements actually align with Scripture. A husband and wife have sexual rights to each other, and it is sinful for them to deprive one another of sexual intimacy without mutual agreement (1 Corinthians 7:3-5). Song of Solomon describes sex metaphorically as food and drink, so married couples should see regular intimacy as necessary, not optional. As we saw with the sin of pornography, a spouse is the primary, God-given antidote to sexual temptation (Proverbs 5:15-21, 1 Corinthians 7:2). While a man is responsible for resisting the temptations of porn and adultery, a wife who regularly refuses her husband physical intimacy is contributing to the problem.
Nevertheless, JP did not obey the full counsel of Scripture regarding sex. At home, he stressed his authority over Mica and insisted that she meet his needs while disregarding her needs. As we saw here, Scripture emphasizes the mutual authority spouses have over each other’s bodies. Addressing the question of “must my wife have sex whenever I want?”, Doug Wilson replies, “Yes, she must have sex whenever you want it. And you must refrain whenever she wants to refrain. You have authority over her body, but never forget that she also has authority over your body”.[13] Scripture commands us to focus on pleasing each other rather than ourselves: “Do nothing from selfish ambition or conceit, but in humility count others more significant than yourselves. Let each of you look not only to his own interests, but also to the interests of others” (Philippians 2:3-4). Therefore, a husband and wife should focus on pleasing each other more than themselves in all aspects of life, including the bedroom (1 Corinthians 7:32-34). Finally, Scripture commands a husband to be satisfied with his wife (Proverbs 5:19), irrespective of how well she “meets his needs”. JP Miller did not approach his wife with this understanding, but with selfishness. He was a sex addict who treated Mica as a drug he could use whenever and however he pleased. That is not biblical patriarchy but abuse cloaked in the terms of Scripture.
Biblical Patriarchs Confront Abusive Pastors
Scripture holds the husband responsible for his wife’s well-being (Ephesians 5:25-32). Biblical patriarchy upholds that clear standard. Complementarianism fails to fully embrace biblical masculinity by downplaying the link between responsibility and authority. This creates confusion that abusers like JP Miller can exploit.
Pastors like JP Miller can be found throughout the country, which highlights a fundamental flaw in how we develop pastors. Many churches prioritize seminary and a stellar resumé. While there is value in a seminary education, it cannot qualify a man for the pastorate. To be biblical, a church will not appoint a man as a pastor unless he meets Scripture’s qualifications:
This is why I left you in Crete, so that you might put what remained into order, and appoint elders in every town as I directed you—if anyone is above reproach, the husband of one wife, and his children are believers and not open to the charge of debauchery or insubordination. For an overseer, as God’s steward, must be above reproach. He must not be arrogant or quick-tempered or a drunkard or violent or greedy for gain, but hospitable, a lover of good, self-controlled, upright, holy, and disciplined. He must hold firm to the trustworthy word as taught, so that he may be able to give instruction in sound doctrine and also to rebuke those who contradict it.
-Titus 1:5-9
This passage and 1 Timothy 3:1-7 emphasize character. A pastor must be above reproach, meaning he gives no occasion or reason for anyone to charge him with wrongdoing. He must be faithful to his wife, raise his children well, and consistently exhibit humility, self-control, contentment, and hospitality. These traits are proven over time, so seminary alone cannot adequately develop and assess them in a potential pastor. Men like JP are hired because they look good on paper. Eventually, their character is revealed when they abuse their authority as he did.
Protecting our pulpits from those abusers requires more deliberate pastoral development within the local church. A man should not attend seminary until the church observes him over several years and determines he possesses the character traits required of a pastor. One of those traits is leading his family well (1 Timothy 3:4), so a man should only be considered if his family is flourishing. That means single men should not be considered unless their faithfulness and leadership can be established in other ways. Only after a man has proven himself should he attend seminary, but only under the full blessing and authority of the local church. Regardless of seminary education, a church should never hire a pastor who has not proven himself faithful. The blessing of his previous church should be a prerequisite unless that church withholds their blessing for unbiblical reasons. This policy would prevent most pastoral abuse.
When abuse comes to light, churches are tempted to overlook it. People are drawn to these churches by the teaching ability and charisma of their pastors, so they might leave if the church confronts the pastor’s sin. Good patriarchs do what is right: confront the pastor and remove him from the pulpit if warranted. They understand that Christ—not the pastor—is the only sure foundation for any church (1 Corinthians 3:11), so they are courageous enough to risk short-term tumult in the church in order kill sin that threatens to destroy the church. Biblical patriarchs follow Paul’s command to Timothy and “wage the good warfare” against such men (1 Timothy 1:20). Church members are abused like Mica Miller because too many churches refuse to confront their abusive pastors.
Conclusion: Patriarchs Build Patriarchs
Most situations like that of Mica Miller and Lindsay Clancy can be prevented by good patriarchs. Biblical patriarchy is key to countering both feminism and misogyny, but only if enough good patriarchs are courageous enough to face these threats. Biblical patriarchs must permeate our institutions, leading to one of the most important responsibilities of any patriarch: replacing himself. Good patriarchs raise up more good patriarchs. Fathers must train their sons to be good patriarchs and their daughters to submit to good patriarchs. Pastors must train men to be good patriarchs then raise up qualified men as elders and deacons. Civic and corporate leaders must train good patriarchs within their own organizations.
Biblical patriarchy is not the solution to every problem in society. As the saying goes, “when you have a hammer, every problem is a nail.” We should not treat biblical patriarchy as the hammer for every nail. However, it is a very versatile hammer and our society is filled with nails, so start hammering!
[1] Catherine Caruso and Tyler Piccotti, “Who is Lindsay Clancy: All About the Duxbury Mother Accused of Killing Her 3 Children”, Biography, 4 September 2026.
[2] Taylor O’Bier, “Lindsay Clancy Case Ends in Mistrial After Jury Deadlock, Defense Appeal Denied”, Scripps News, 4 September 2026.
[3] Susan Hatters Friedman and Phillip J Resnick, “Child Murder by Mothers: Patterns and Prevention”, World Psychiatry 6:3: 2007: 137-141.
[4] Jared Downing, “Wave of Moms Killing their Kids in Wake of Lindsay Clancy Case May Not Be a Coincidence: Expert”, New York Post, 23 October 2026.
[5] Samantha Bergeson, “The Heartbreaking True Story of Mica Miller and Netflix’s Death of the Pastor’s Wife”, Time, 24 August 2026.
[6] Nicole Russell, “Opinion: Mica Miller Deserves Justice. This Netflix Series is a Start”, USA Today, 2 September 2026.
[7] Troy Pozirekides, “Death of the Pastor’s Wife: Where the Mica Miller Case Stands Now”, Netflix Tudum, 26 August 2026.
[8] Kalia Richardson, “Where is Pastor John-Paul Miller Now?: Update on ‘Death of a Pastor’s Wife’ Case”, USA Today, 27 August 2026.
[9][9] Troy Pozirekides, “Death of the Pastor’s Wife: Where the Mica Miller Case Stands Now”, Netflix Tudum, 26 August 2026; Kelly Allen and Charlote Walsh, “Where is Pastor John-Paul Miller Now?: Inside His Lfie as He Awaits Trial After Wife Mica Miller’s Death”, People, 26 August 2026
[10] Nicole Russell, “Opinion: Mica Miller Deserves Justice. This Netflix Series is a Start”, USA Today, 2 September 2026.
[11] Kelly Allen, “What to Know About Mica Miller’s Life with Pastor John-Paul Miller Before and After She Accused Him of Abuse”, People, 28 August 2026.
[12] Troy Pozirekides, “Death of the Pastor’s Wife: Where the Mica Miller Case Stands Now”, Netflix Tudum, 26 August 2026.
[13] Douglas Wilson, Fidelity: How to Be a One-Woman Man, Moscow, ID: Canon Press: 2012: 167.
Next Post
Previous Post